T. AL‐SHEMMERI
WIND TURBINES
DOWNLOAD FREE TEXTBOOKS AT
BOOKBOON.COM NO REGISTRATION NEEDED
Download free books at BookBooN.com
2
T. Al-Shemmeri
Wind Turbines
Download free books at BookBooN.com
3
Wind Turbines© 2010 T. Al-Shemmeri & Ventus Publishing ApSISBN 978-87-7681-692-6
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
4
Contents
Contents Preface 7
Dimensions and units 9
1 Energy & the Environment 151.1 Introduction 151.2 Forms of energy 151.2.1 Mechanical energy 161.2.2 Electrical energy 171.2.3 Chemical energy 181.2.4 Nuclear energy 191.2.5 Thermal energy 201.3 Energy conversion 201.4 Environmental Impact from fossil fuels 231.5 Energy world-wide 25
2 Wind Energy 272.1 Introduction 272.2 Siting of Wind turbines 282.3 Planning Constraints for wind turbines: 302.3.1 Steps to Planning and Building a Wind Farm 302.4 Wind Energy and the Environment 33
We have ambitions. Also for you.
SimCorp is a global leader in financial software. At SimCorp, you will be part of a large network of competent
and skilled colleagues who all aspire to reach common goals with dedication and team spirit. We invest in our
employees to ensure that you can meet your ambitions on a personal as well as on a professional level. SimCorp
employs the best qualified people within economics, finance and IT, and the majority of our colleagues have a
university or business degree within these fields.
Ambitious? Look for opportunities at www.simcorp.com/careers
www.simcorp.com
Ple
ase
clic
k th
e ad
vert
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
5
Contents
2.4.1 Positive environmental benefits of Wind energy 332.4.2 Negative Impacts of Wind energy 33
3 Theory of Wind Energy 383.1 Conservation of Mass: 383.2 Conservation of Energy: 393.3 Conservation of Momentum 403.4 Ideal Wind Power calculations: 413.3.1 Theory of Wind Turbines 423.3.2 Distinction between rated and actual power output of the turbine 44
4 Wind Turbines types and components 464.1 Types of Wind Turbines 464.2 Components of a Wind Turbine 464.3 Relationship between Wind speed and Rotor speed 49
5 Wind Energy Measurements 505.1 Electrical measurements 505.1.1 Ohms Law 515.1.2 Electrical Power 515.1.3 Alternating Current Power 515.1.4 Electrical Measurements 535.2 Velocity and flow measured by Anemometers 555.2.1 The ‘cup type’ air speed measurement 555.2.2 The ‘vane anemometer’ 55
what‘s missing in this equation?
maeRsK inteRnationaL teChnoLogY & sCienCe PRogRamme
You could be one of our future talents
Are you about to graduate as an engineer or geoscientist? Or have you already graduated?If so, there may be an exciting future for you with A.P. Moller - Maersk.
www.maersk.com/mitas
Ple
ase
clic
k th
e ad
vert
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
6
Contents
5.2.3 The ‘hot-wire’ anemometer’ 575.3 Measurement of speed of rotation 575.3.1 Mechanical Tachometer 575.3.2 Electrical Tachometers 585.3.3 Stroboscope 595.3.4 Magnetic Field Angular Position Sensors 595.3.5 Wheel encoder 615.4 The importance of speed in Turbine’s measurements 61
6 Worked Examples 63
7 Tutorial Problems 73
8 Case Study 768.1 Site Survey of wind energy and wind turbine matching 768.2 Introduction 778.3 Energy and power in the wind 778.4 Estimating the Annual Energy Output (A.E.O.) 788.5 The Software Package 798.6 Discussion 848.7 Conclusions 878.8 References 87
Ple
ase
clic
k th
e ad
vert
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
7
Preface
Preface This book is concerned with the subject of Wind Energy, as a source of clean and renewable and free for all. The need for this type of book is very well documented, the current consumption of energy is unsustainable and humans have to change their habits and or utilise this source, but there is so much work before we can rely completely on renewable energy. This book aims to describe the fundamentals of wind energy and the pertinent parameters that control the amount of energy available from a given wind turbine. Coal fuelled the industrial revolution in the 18th and 19th century. It remained as the prime fuel supplying steam engines used in road vehicles and rail road trucks. The industrialised nations were in huge competition in their search for additional fuels and the discovery of oil in the Middle East and elsewhere extended the use oil opening the applications to a wider range. With the advent of the automobile, airplanes and the spreading use of electricity, oil became the dominant fuel during the twentieth century. The Arab-Israeli wars in the 1967 and 1972; the price of oil increased from 5 to 45 US dollars per barrel, there was a shift away from oil. Coal and nuclear became the fuels of choice for electricity generation and conservation measures increased energy efficiency. The use of fossil fuels has continued to grow and their share of the energy supply has increased. The more recent invasion of Iran, and subsequently Kuwait and the eventual occupation of Iraq are all clear evidence of the importance of oil to the west. In 2008, total worldwide energy consumption was 474 exajoules (474×1018 J) with 80 to 90 percent derived from the combustion of fossil fuels. The estimates of remaining non-renewable worldwide energy resources vary, with the remaining fossil fuels totaling an estimated 400000 EJ (1 EJ = 1018J) and the available nuclear fuel such as uranium exceeding 2500000 EJ. The Sun, provides the world with a renewable usable energy of 3800000 EJ/yr, dwarfing all non-renewable resources. However, it is there to be utilised. The sun energy needs to be harnessed, stored, and converted into the required form for a particular use. Whatever fossil fuel remains will be more and more difficult to mine, and as it become scarcer the security of supply will become a major issue, with the definite outcome that the cost will exponentially increase and that would lead ultimately to major quarrels and possibly wars. In order to move away from fossil fuels it is expected to create economic pressure through Carbon trading and Green taxation. Some countries are taking action as a result of the Kyoto Protocol, and further steps in this direction are proposed. For example, the European Union Commission has proposed that the Energy Policy should set a binding target of increasing the level of renewable energy in the EU's overall mix from less than 7% today to 20% by 2020. Wind Energy is natural and renewable, wind turbines are similar to hydraulic turbines, hence the technology is mature and well establish. What is good about wind energy, its available even in winter, when solar energy is not so good, so it makes a natural compliment to solar energy. Wind energy is becoming popular despite some concerns about visual impact and so on, and it is one of the most competitive renewable energy in most cases. According to the World Wind Energy Association, the installed capacity of wind power increased by 29% from the end of 2007 to the end of 2008 to total 121 GW, with over half the increase in the United States, Spain and China.
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
8
Preface
This book tackles the fundamental principles of wind energy; and how it can be harnessed and used efficiently. A case study is provided at the end of the book to demonstrate how best to evaluate the wind energy potential for a locality, plan, select the best wind turbine for that particular application, and use wind energy.
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
9
Dimensions and units
Dimensions and units Any physical situation, whether it involves a single object or a complete system, can be described in terms of a number of recognisable properties which the object or system possesses. For example, a moving object could be described in terms of its mass, length, area or volume, velocity and acceleration. Its temperature or electrical properties might also be of interest, while other properties - such as density and viscosity of the medium through which it moves - would also be of importance, since they would affect its motion. These measurable properties used to describe the physical state of the body or system are known as its variables, some of which are basic such as length and time, others are derived such as velocity. Each variable has units to describe the magnitude of that quantity. Lengths in SI units are described in units of meters. The meter is the unit of the dimension of length (L); hence the area will have dimension of L2, and volume L3. Time will have units of seconds (T), hence velocity is a derived quantity with dimensions of (LT-1) and units of meter per second. A list of some variables is given in Table 1 with their units and dimensions. Definitions of Some Basic SI Units Mass: The kilogram is the mass of a platinum-iridium cylinder kept at Sevres in France. Length: The metre is now defined as being equal to 1 650 763.73 wavelengths in vacuum of the
orange line emitted by the Krypton-86 atom. Time: The second is defined as the fraction 1/31 556 925.975 of the tropical year for 1900. The
second is also declared to be the interval occupied by 9 192 631 770 cycles of the radiation of the caesium atom corresponding to the transition between two closely spaced ground state energy levels.
Temperature: The Kelvin is the degree interval on the thermodynamic scale on which the temperature of the triple point of water is 273.16 K exactly. (The temperature of the ice point is 273.15 K).
Definitions of Some Derived SI Units Force:
The Newton is that force which, when acting on a mass of one kilogram gives it an acceleration of one metre per second per second.
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
10
Dimensions and units
Work Energy, and Heat:
The joule is the work done by a force of one Newton when its point of application is moved through a distance of one metre in the direction of the force. The same unit is used for the measurement of every kind of energy including quantity of heat. The Newton metre, the joule and the watt second are identical in value. It is recommended that the Newton is kept of the measurement of torque or moment and the joule or watt second is used for quantities of work or energy.
Quantity Unit Symbol
Length [L] Metre m
Mass [m] Kilogram kg
Time [ t ] Second s
Electric current [ I ] Ampere A
Temperature [ T ] degree Kelvin K
Luminous intensity [ Iv ] Candela cd
Table 1: Basic SI Units.
Quantity Unit Symbol Derivation
Force [ F ] Newton N kg-m/s2
Work, energy [ E ] joule J N-m
Power [ P ] watt W J/s
Pressure [ p ] Pascal Pa N/m2
Table 2: Derived Units with Special Names
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
11
Dimensions and units
Quantity Symbol
Area m2
Volume m3
Density kg/m3
Angular acceleration rad/s2
Velocity m/s
Pressure, stress N/m2
Kinematic viscosity m2/s
Dynamic viscosity N-s/m2
Momentum kg-m/s
Kinetic energy kg-m2/s2
Specific enthalpy J/kg
Specific entropy J/kg K
Table 3: Some Examples of Other Derived SI Units
Quantity Unit Symbol Derivation
Time minute min 60 s
Time hour h 3.6 ks
Temperature degree Celsius oC K - 273.15
Angle degree o /180 rad
Volume litre l 10-3 m3 or dm3
Speed kilometre per hour km/h -
Angular speed revolution per minute rev/min -
Frequency hertz Hz cycle/s
Pressure bar b 102 kN/m2
Kinematic viscosity stoke St 100 mm2/s
Dynamic viscosity poise P 100 mN-s/m2
Table 4: Non-SI Units
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
12
Dimensions and units
Name Symbol Factor Number
exa E 1018 1,000,000,000,000,000,000
Peta P 1015 1,000,000,000,000,000
tera T 1012 1,000,000,000,000
giga G 109 1,000,000,000
mega M 106 1,000,000
kilo k 103 1,000
hecto h 102 100
deca da 10 10
deci d 10-1 0.1
centi c 10-2 0.01
milli m 10-3 0.001
micro 10-6 0.000001
nano n 10-9 0.000000001
pico p 10-12 0.000000000001
fempto f 10-15 0.000000000000001
atto a 10-18 0.000000000000000001
Table 5: Multiples of Units
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
13
Dimensions and units
item conversion
Length
1 in = 25.4 mm 1 ft = 0.3048 m 1 yd = 0.9144 m 1 mile = 1.609 km
Mass 1 lb. = 0.4536 kg (0.453 592 37 exactly)
Area
1 in2 = 645.2 mm2 1 ft2 = 0.092 90 m2 1 yd2 = 0.8361 m2 1 acre = 4047 m2
Volume
1 in3 = 16.39 cm3 1 ft3 = 0.028 32 m3 = 28.32 litre 1 yd3 = 0.7646 m3 = 764.6 litre 1 UK gallon = 4.546 litre 1 US gallon = 3.785 litre
Force, Weight 1 lbf = 4.448 N
Density 1 lb/ft3 = 16.02 kg/m3
Velocity 1 km/h = 0.2778 m/s 1 ft/s = 0.3048 m/s 1 mile/h = 0.4470 m/s = 1.609 km/h
Pressure, Stress 1000 Pa = 1000 N/m2 = 0.01 bar 1 in H2O = 2.491 mb 1 lbf/in2 (Psi)= 68.95 mb or 1 bar = 14.7 Psi
Power 1 horsepower = 745.7 W
Moment, Torque 1 ft-pdl = 42.14 mN-m
Rates of Flow 1 gal/h = 1.263 ml/s = 4.546 l/h 1 ft3/s = 28.32 l/s
Fuel Consumption 1 mile/gal = 0.3540 km/l
Kinematic Viscosity 1 ft2/s = 929.0 cm2/s = 929.0 St
Dynamic Viscosity 1 lbf-s/ft2 = 47.88 N-s/m2 = 478.8 P 1 pdl-s/ft2 = 1.488 N-s/m2 = 14.88 P 1cP = 1 mN-s/m2
Energy
1 horsepower-h = 2.685 MJ 1 kW-h = 3.6 MJ 1 Btu = 1.055 kJ 1 therm = 105.5 MJ
Table 6: Conversion Factors
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
14
Dimensions and units
Unit X Factor = Unit x Factor = Unit
Length (L) ins ft
25.4 0.305
mm m
0.0394 3.281
ins ft
Area (A) in2
ft2 645.16 0.093
mm2 m2
0.0016 10.76
in2 ft2
Volume (V) in3
ft3 ft3 pints Imp. gal Imp. gal
16.387 0.0283 28.32 0.5682 4.546 0.0045
mm3 m3 litre litre litre m3
0.000061 35.31 0.0353 1.7598 0.22 220
in3 ft3 ft3 pints Imp gal Imp gal
Mass (M) lb. tonne
0.4536 1000
kg kg
2.2046
lb.
Force (F) lb. 4.448 N 0.2248 lb.
Velocity (V) ft/min 0.0051 m/sec 196.85 ft/min
Volume Flow Imp gal/min Imp gal/h ft3/min
0.0758 0.00013 0.00047
litres/s m3/s m3/s
13.2 7,936.5 2,118.6
Imp gal/min Imp gal/h ft3/min
Pressure (P) lb/in2 kg/cm2
0.0689 0.9807
bar bar
14.5 1.02
lb/in2 kg/cm2
Density () lb/ft3 16.019 kg/m3 0.0624 lb/ft3
Heat Flow Rate (Q)
Btu/h kcal/h
0.2931 1.163
W W
3.412 0.8598
Btu/h kcal/h
Thermal Conductivity (k)
Btu/ft h R kcal/m h K
1.731 1.163
W/m K W/m K
0.5777 0.8598
Btu/ft h R kcal/m h K
Thermal Conductance (U)
Btu/h ft2 R kcal/h m2 K
5.678 1.163
W/m2 K W/m2 K
0.1761 0.8598
Btu/h ft2 R kcal/h m2 K
Enthalpy (h)
Btu/lb. kcal/kg
2,326 4,187
J/kg J/kg
0.00043 0.00024
Btu/lb. kcal/kg
Table 7: Conversion Factors
Simply multiply the imperial by a constant factor to convert into Metric or the other way around.
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
15
Energy & the Environment
1 Energy & the Environment 1.1 Introduction Energy is needed for two functions:
a. To provide heating, cooking and processing of fluids b. To provide electricity to drive machines, or power lights.
The following sections will discuss the various forms of energy, and how energy can be converted from one form to another which convenient for heating, cooling etc.
1.2 Forms of energy We associate energy with devices whose inputs are fuel based such as electrical current, coal, oil or natural gas; resulting in outputs such as movement, heat or light. Unit of energy is the Joule (J). The rate of producing energy is POWER which has the unit of Joule per second or the Watt (W).
it’s an interesting world
Where it’sStudent and Graduate opportunities in IT, Internet & EngineeringCheltenham | £competitive + benefits
Part of the UK’s intelligence services, our role is to counter threats that compromise national and globalsecurity. We work in one of the most diverse, creative and technically challenging IT cultures. Throw incontinuous professional development, and you get truly interesting work, in a genuinely inspirational business.
To find out more visit www.careersinbritishintelligence.co.uk
Applicants must be British citizens. GCHQ values diversity and welcomes applicants from all sections of the community. We want our workforce to reflect the diversity of our work.
Ple
ase
clic
k th
e ad
vert
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
16
Energy & the Environment
There are FIVE forms of Energy:
Mechanical Energy Electrical Energy Chemical Energy Nuclear Energy Thermal Energy
These energy forms are discussed in the following sections. 1.2.1 Mechanical energy This type of energy is associated with the ability to perform physical work. There are two forms in which this energy is found; namely potential energy and kinetic energy.
Potential energy
As the name implies is contained in a body due to its height above its surroundings, examples such as the gravitational energy of the water behind a dam, and the energy stored in batteries. Potential Energy = mass x acceleration due to gravity (9.81) x height above datum Ep = m x g x h The energy produced by one kilogram of water falling from a height of 100m above ground is a potential energy, which can be calculated as follows: Potential Energy = mass x acceleration due to gravity x height above datum Ep = 1 x 9.81 x 100 = 981 J/kg
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
17
Energy & the Environment
Kinetic energy
Kinetic energy is related to the movement of the body in question. Examples of KE such as the flywheel effect and the energy of water flowing in a stream. Kinetic Energy = ½ mass x velocity squared Ek = ½ x m x v2 The water stream in a river flowing at a velocity of 2 m/s has a kinetic energy of: Kinetic Energy = ½ mass x velocity squared = ½ x 1 x (2)2 = 2 J/kg 1.2.2 Electrical energy This type of energy as the name implies is associated with the electrons of materials. Electrical energy exists in two forms:
a. Electrostatic electricity This type of electrical energy is produced by the accumulation of charge on the plates of a capacitor. Charles Coulomb first described electric field strengths in the 1780's. He found that for point charges, the electrical force varies directly with the product of the charges. The greater the charges, the stronger the field. And the field varies inversely with the square of the distance between the charges. This means that the greater the distance, the weaker the force becomes. The formula for electrostatic force, F, is given as: F = k (q1 X q2) / d2 Where q1 and q2 are the charges, d is the distance between the charges. And k is the proportionality constant which depend on the material separating the charges. b. Electromagnetic energy This type is produced with a combination of magnetic and electric forces. It exists as a continuous spectrum of radiation. The most useful type of electromagnetic energy comes in the form of solar radiation transmitted by the sun that forms the basis of all terrestrial life.
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
18
Energy & the Environment
1.2.3 Chemical energy This type of is associated with the release of thermal energy due to a chemical reaction of certain substances with oxygen. Burning wood, coal or gas is the main source of energy we commonly use in heating and cooking.
Calculation of chemical energy The energy liberated from the combustion of a given mass of fuel, with a known calorific value in a combustion chamber of known efficiency is given by: Chemical Energy = Mass of fuel x calorific value x efficiency of combustion
Ple
ase
clic
k th
e ad
vert
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
19
Energy & the Environment
1.2.4 Nuclear energy This energy is stored in the nucleus of matter, and is released as a result of interactions within the atomic nucleus.
There are three nuclear reactions: a. Radioactive decay: In which one unstable nucleus (radioisotope) decays into a more stable configuration resulting in the release of matter and energy b. Fission: A heavy nucleus absorbs a neutron splitting it into two or more nuclei accompanied by a release of energy. Uranium U235 has the ability to produce 70x109 J/kg Einstein proposed the following equation to calculate the energy produced from nuclear fissioning (i.e. conversion of matter (m) into energy, E are related to the speed of light C) : E = m C2 This reaction forms the bases for current nuclear power generation plants. c. Fusion: Two light nuclei combine to produce a more stable configuration accompanied by the release of energy. Heavy water (Deuterium) fusion reaction may produce energy at the rate of 0.35x1012 J/kg. This reaction is yet to be realised to produce electricity on commercial basis.
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
20
Energy & the Environment
1.2.5 Thermal energy
Thermal energy is associated with intermolecular vibration resulting in heat and a temperature rise above that of the surroundings. Thermal energy is calculated for two different regimes: When the substance in a pure phase, say if it is in a liquid, gas or solid, then Thermal Energy = mass x specific heat capacity x temperature difference During a change of phase, such as evaporation or condensation, it can be calculated by: Thermal Energy = mass x latent heat However, if there is a change of phase, say during the condensation of water vapour into liquid, there is an additional amount of heat released while the temperature remains constant during the change of phase. For 1 kg of water to be heated at ambient pressure from 20 to 120 oC, the requirement is Thermal energy = heating water (20-100) oC + evaporation at 100 oC + super-heating vapour (100-120) oC Thermal energy = 1x 4.219 x (100-20) + 1x2256.7 + 1x2.01x(120-100) = 337.52 + 2256.7 + 40.2 = 2634.42 kJ
1.3 Energy conversion It is important to understand that losses are encountered during the transformation of energy during the different conversions into the final form for a given application, for example consider a wind turbine, the following conversions take place: Kinetic energy of the oncoming air strikes the rotor blades, turning them, and hence the axial kinetic energy is turned into mechanical energy of the rotating blades. Some of this mechanical energy is lost in the control mechanism, consisting of the gear box and brake to regulate the speed and match it with that of the generator. Some energy losses are encountered due to friction.
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
21
Energy & the Environment
The shaft turning with the remaining energy will rotate in turn the generator; hence converting it’s the output into electrical energy (mechanical to electrical). Some losses are dissipated through the mechanical connections between the turbine and the electrical generator. Electricity is used by customers for lighting / heating or to operate electric devices such as radio, television, etc. electrical devices are designed to operate on an optimum condition; efficiency of the operation will vary depending on its use, age and maintenance. The energy flow for a typical wind turbine is shown in Figure 1.1; can be analysed in a simple way by considering the energy flow diagram, which may look like this: 100 units of energy are stored in the incoming air as kinetic energy. 40 units are converted into rotational /mechanical energy by the blades. 35 units are transferred by the shaft; some units are absorbed by the brake and gear. 33 units are converted from mechanical into electrical energy in the electrical generator. 30 units is the net output, as 3 units are lost in voltage conversion, storage and distribution. The final figure depends on many factors, including the type of turbine, efficiency of the control system, efficiency of the generator, and the quality of the transformer and the distribution system.
In Paris or OnlineInternational programs taught by professors and professionals from all over the world
BBA in Global BusinessMBA in International Management / International MarketingDBA in International Business / International ManagementMA in International EducationMA in Cross-Cultural CommunicationMA in Foreign Languages
Innovative – Practical – Flexible – Affordable
Visit: www.HorizonsUniversity.orgWrite: [emailprotected]: 01.42.77.20.66 www.HorizonsUniversity.org
Ple
ase
clic
k th
e ad
vert
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
22
Energy & the Environment
Figure 1.1 Energy conversions in a typical Wind Turbine.
Courtesy of: howStuffWorks.
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
23
Energy & the Environment
From \ To Mechanical Electrical Thermal Chemical Nuclear
Mechanical Gear Nutcracker push mower
Electric generator
friction
x
Electrical Electric motor
Light bulb
Electric fire
Electrolysis
Particle accelerator
Thermal Steam turbine
Thermo-couple
Heat exchanger
x
Fusion reactor
Chemical jet engine Rocket
Battery fuel cell
Car engine Boiler
Intermediate reaction
x
Nuclear x
x
Nuclear reactor
x
x
Table 1.1 Energy conversion matrix
1.4 Environmental Impact from fossil fuels Coal, Oil and Natural gas have their relative merits in terms of availability, price and thermal performance. Table 1.3 below is constructed for comparison of the heat capacity, CO2 and SO2 production by the three fossil fuels. The 4th column is of particular importance in comparing all three fuels; it represents the quantity of carbon dioxide emitted for every unit of energy produced. Coal produces the highest amount of Carbon dioxide for a given output of energy; then oil, then Natural gas which produces nearly half the emission of coal and a third less than that of oil.
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
24
Energy & the Environment
The results displayed in table 1.3 for the production of CO2 mass per unit energy compares well with data published by the UK government, Action on Energy, the values found in this chapter are lower than those quoted in the reference, the difference is that the calculations shown in this chapter were only concerned with the combustion process itself; there other knock on effect in the calculations when the life cycle of the fuel is considered, hence the addition of energy used to transport, process the fuel, and to include distribution losses.
Fuel
Calorific Value MJ/kg
CO2
kg / kg fuel
CO2 / Energy
kg / MJ
SO2
kg / kg fuel
Coal
26
2.361
0.091
0.018
Oil
42
3.153
0.075
0.040
Natural Gas
55
2.750
0.050
Table 1.3 Environmental impacts of fossil fuels
At NNE Pharmaplan we need ambitious people to help us achieve the challenging goals which have been laid down for the company.
Kim Visby is an example of one of our many ambitious co-workers. Besides being a manager in the Manufacturing IT department, Kim performs triathlon at a professional level.
‘NNE Pharmaplan offers me freedom with responsibility as well as the opportunity to plan my own time. This enables me to perform triath-lon at a competitive level, something I would not have the possibility of doing otherwise.’
‘By balancing my work and personal life, I obtain the energy to perform my best, both at work and in triathlon.’
If you are ambitious and want to join our world of opportunities, go to nnepharmaplan.com
NNE Pharmaplan is the world’s leading engineering and consultancy company focused exclusively on the pharma and biotech industries. NNE Pharmaplan is a company in the Novo Group.
wanted: ambitious people
Ple
ase
clic
k th
e ad
vert
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
25
Energy & the Environment
1.5 Energy world-wide
The consumption of energy by humankind has evolved over the ages. It began with the invention of fire, man relied on wood burning to cook and to provide warmth and light for millions of years. As civilisation evolved, the needs for energy became greater and other sources were sought. In the long search, man discovered coal. Over the years coal provided much greater resource for energy, encouraging man to push its use into further applications. A major leap in the nineteenth century was achieved by the discovery of oil in the Middle East. This unfortunate discovery eventually led to TWO World wars as the leading industrial nations attempted to dominate the world market and to secure the energy supply for their huge manufacturing industries. The oil crises due to the Arab-Israeli war in 1973 resulted in tripling of oil prices, this was a major shock for non producing countries, particularly in Europe, on one hand it has put tremendous increase on the energy consumer’s budget; The discovery of oil pushed the competition for manufacturing beyond the industrialised countries own borders. This competition for shares in the exports market put so much strain on the consumption of fossil fuel. Hubbert put foreword his caution when he published his famous curve (1956), Figure 1.2. I t is clear that the oil reserves of the world are consumed unsustainably and will be exhausted within this century. Humans have to find a new source or sources of energy to replace oil. However, on the positive side, the depletion of oil can be considered as a major advantage to humankind and the environment, it will force consumers to reduce the excessive consumption of energy, it will help man to review manufacturing processes and attempt to increase energy efficiency, and probably it has already pushed governments to search for newer sources of energy. Substantial funds are allocated for the research into renewable resources such as Hydropower, wind turbines and solar energy. Energy consumption world-wide has continued to rise, it is estimated that in 1900, the world consumption was around 22 EJ and by 1960 it rose to 128 EJ; this reached 564 EJ in 2000. The continued increase in population and the associated increase in manufacturing industry to cater for greater dependence of man on energy driven devices and the culture of multi-car ownership has put even greater importance for energy. It is interesting to note that the energy consumption for individuals have increased by 10 folds over the century mentioned above. This is another proof that we are becoming too excessive and becoming too dependant on energy far greater than we did before.
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
26
Energy & the Environment
Figure 1.2 the first wake up call by Hubbert.
Courtesy of wikimedia.org
“I have only positive impressions of BI so far. BI provides good quality educationand a broad course portfolio. Many of the courses are based on business cases,which give direct practical skills. The lecturers have solid domestic and international experience which is very inspiring. BI provides various student organisations, whereyou can socialise and gain life time experience”.
Alla Mamonova, Russia, MSc in Business and Economics
BI Norwegian School of Management (BI) offers a wide range of Master of Science (MSc) programmes in:
For more information, visit www.bi.edu/mscBI also offers programmes at Bachelor, Masters, Executive MBA and PhD levels. Visit www.bi.edu for more information.
EFMD
CLICK HEREfor the best
investment in your career
APPLYNOW
LOOKING TO DEVELOP YOUR BUSINESS CAREER?
Ple
ase
clic
k th
e ad
vert
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
27
Wind Energy
2 Wind Energy
2.1 Introduction
Figure 2.1 Wind Power developments
Courtesy of – http://www.wwindea.org/ According to BWEA, the British Wind Energy Authority, in the UK currently there are 2896 large Wind turbines with installed capacity of 4532 MW, sufficient to supply over 2.5 million homes (based on annual household energy consumption of 4.7 MWh).
Much attention has been paid recently to Renewables as a potential source of fuel. The rising oil price and the logistics in supplying fossil fuel to remote areas are the main drive to Renewables as well as the environmental incentive. In remote locations, stand-alone Renewable energy systems can be more cost-effective than extending a power line to the electricity grid. In addition, the environmental benefits under the current international concerns on global warming makes such project much more valuable and rewarding. The growth of renewable energy sources also stimulates employment, the creation of new technologies and new skills.
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
28
Wind Energy
The new Directive on renewable energy sets ambitious targets for all Member States, such that the EU will reach a 20% share of energy from renewable sources by 2020 and a 10% share of renewable energy specifically in the transport sector. It also improves the legal framework for promoting renewable electricity, requires national action plans that establish pathways for the development of renewable energy sources including bioenergy, creates cooperation mechanisms to help achieve the targets cost effectively and establishes the sustainability criteria for Biofuels. The new Directive should be implemented by Member States by early in 2010. In a recent statement, Ed Miliband, UK Secretary of State for Energy and Climate change he spelled out the government strategy:
“Transforming the country into a cleaner, greener and more prosperous place to live is at the heart of our economic plans for 'building Britain’s future' and ensuring the UK is ready to take advantage of the opportunities ahead”. By 2020:
More than 1.2 million people will be in green jobs. 7 million homes will have benefited from whole house makeovers, and more than 1.5 million
households will be supported to produce their own clean energy. Around 40 percent of electricity will be from low-carbon sources, from Renewables, nuclear and
clean coal. We will be importing half the amount of gas that we otherwise would. The average new car will emit 40 percent less carbon than now.
2.2 Siting of Wind turbines The placement or "siting" of wind systems is extremely important. In order for a wind turbine system to be effective, a relatively consistent wind-flow is required. Obstructions such as trees or hills can interfere with the rotors. Because of this, the rotors are usually placed on towers to take advantage of the stronger winds available higher up. Furthermore, wind speed varies with temperature, season, and time of day. All these factors must be considered when choosing a site for a wind-powered generator. The amount of Wind Energy available at any location depends on two sets of factors:
a. Climatic factors including: Time of day, Season, Geographic location, Topography, and Local weather.
b. Mechanical factors including: Diameter of rotor, and Type of Turbine Utility-scale wind farms must have access to transmission lines to transport energy. The wind farm developer may be obligated to install extra equipment or control systems in the wind farm to meet the technical standards set by the operator of a transmission line.
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
29
Wind Energy
Figure 2.2 Wind farm, off shore, or on shore.
Dedicated Analytical SolutionsFOSSSlangerupgade 693400 HillerødTel. +45 70103370
www.foss.dk
The Family owned FOSS group is
the world leader as supplier of
dedicated, high-tech analytical
solutions which measure and
control the quality and produc-
tion of agricultural, food, phar-
maceutical and chemical produ-
cts. Main activities are initiated
from Denmark, Sweden and USA
with headquarters domiciled in
Hillerød, DK. The products are
marketed globally by 23 sales
companies and an extensive net
of distributors. In line with
the corevalue to be ‘First’, the
company intends to expand
its market position.
Employees at FOSS Analytical A/S are living proof of the company value - First - using new inventions to make dedicated solutions for our customers. With sharp minds and cross functional teamwork, we constantly strive to develop new unique products - Would you like to join our team?
FOSS works diligently with innovation and development as basis for its growth. It is reflected in the fact that more than 200 of the 1200 employees in FOSS work with Re-search & Development in Scandinavia and USA. Engineers at FOSS work in production, development and marketing, within a wide range of different fields, i.e. Chemistry, Electronics, Mechanics, Software, Optics, Microbiology, Chemometrics.
Sharp Minds - Bright Ideas!
We offerA challenging job in an international and innovative company that is leading in its field. You will get the opportunity to work with the most advanced technology together with highly skilled colleagues.
Read more about FOSS at www.foss.dk - or go directly to our student site www.foss.dk/sharpminds where you can learn more about your possibilities of working together with us on projects, your thesis etc.
Ple
ase
clic
k th
e ad
vert
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
30
Wind Energy
2.3 Planning Constraints for wind turbines: There is a number of planning related issues that may make it difficult for you to install a turbine on your site and it would be wise to ensure that you are not going to fall foul of any of these before proceeding.
o Military installations. Avoid these installations, especially if it is an air force base or communication centres.
o Proximity to built-up area.
When housing estates are concerned, ideally consider a distance of at least 200m - 300m depending on the size of the turbine.
o Designated areas or listed buildings.
National Parks or Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty are more difficult to satisfy the local planning officer to install a wind turbine on it or near it.
2.3.1 Steps to Planning and Building a Wind Farm There are many stages of development before a wind turbine/farm can be approved and built. Once a site has been selected for its good overall potential, work begins on several main tasks:
Consultation with the local authority It is extremely important to contact the local authority in the area where the turbine is considered before committing any time or costs. Engage them early in the planning process, answer any questions and/or concerns that they might have, and keep an open dialogue with them throughout the whole development.
Consultation with the Public near the site
The local community who are likely to be affected by the proposal must be met to present the project, solicit their feedback and seek their support. An advertisem*nt in the local paper would be a good idea to inform the general public and invite them for a discussion and debate.
Land acquisition
Early in the process, developers, if not already the owners themselves usually approach landowners to negotiate “option” agreements to use their land. As the project progresses, the developer will seek to convert the options into firm land lease agreements.
Wind Assessment
Another very important step is assessing the wind resource. Scientists and engineers use meteorological masts to measure wind speed and other climatic conditions for at least one year. This data is then used to estimate how much energy the wind farm will produce. It is often assumed that this has to be carried out before any serious consideration is planned.
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
31
Wind Energy
Wind Farm Design This is important if the project is a wind farm, Wind data is combined with topographical information to design the wind farm. Engineers use this data to model wind flow, turbine performance, sound levels and other parameters to optimize the location of the wind turbines. They also design the access roads, turbine foundations and local electric network, as well as the connection to the electricity grid.
Figure 2.3 Wind farm optimal placement
Environmental Impact Assessment Environmental assessments are conducted to identify any impacts on landscape, plants and wildlife, soil and water, land use or other activities such as aviation and telecommunications. If negative impacts are identified, the design is adjusted to avoid or mitigate them.
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
32
Wind Energy
Economic and Financial evaluation To prove the economic viability of the project in order to raise the funds to build the wind farm. On one hand, there is a need to estimate the cost of turbines and their installation, as well as roads, electrical system, operation and maintenance, etc. On the other hand, there is a need to estimate the income from the energy production of the wind farm over the lifetime of the project. If there is a net profit, the project has a chance to succeed.
Site Preparation
Build access roads and clear the areas where turbines will be erected; then prepare the foundations; do the excavating, followed by installing the formworks and pouring concrete.
Construction The wind turbine parts are manufactured and pre-assembled into the main components at the factory then shipped to the wind farm site where the final assembly will take place. When all components have been received, the assembly can take place. A crane is used to erect the tower and install the nacelle and rotor with its hub and blades. On the ground, the electrical collection network is installed and connected to the grid through the substation.
Commissioning
Finally, the wind turbine is tested, all components are calibrated on site and verified against the suppliers specifications, before becoming fully operational.
Ple
ase
clic
k th
e ad
vert
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
33
Wind Energy
2.4 Wind Energy and the Environment In this section, both the positive and negative aspects of wind energy will be discussed. 2.4.1 Positive environmental benefits of Wind energy It must be stressed that wind energy involves no combustion or nuclear reaction, so it is pollution free. It is renewable and plentiful and free, and what is more it is available everywhere, especially in remote areas and often it is windier in mountains and near costal areas. There are significant environmental benefits obtained from using a renewable energy device attributed to preventing the release of Green house gases associated with fossil fuels. The general equation for estimating the reduction in emitted gas is:Gas-emission reduction (in tonnes) = A x 0.8 x h x kG Where A is the rated capacity of the development in kW h is the number of operational hours per year, = 8000 h kG is the specific emitted gas constant. Hence the following equations are used to predict environmental benefits from based on 1 kWe system:
CO2 emission reduction (in tonnes) = 1x0.8x8000x862/106 = 5.5 SO2 emission reduction (in tonnes) = 1x0.8x8000x9.9/106 = 0.063 NO2 emission reduction (in tonnes) = 1x0.8x8000x862/106 = 0.018 2.4.2 Negative Impacts of Wind energy These issues are often raised, some are valid, some are opinion driven, and others could be due to personal preferences or biasness.
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
34
Wind Energy
a. Noise Wind turbines rely on the movement of the rotor affected by wind to rotate the generator and make electricity. Virtually everything with moving parts will make some sound, and wind turbines are no exception. Turbines are an established and well developed technology, and well designed wind turbines are generally quiet in operation, and compared to the noise of road traffic, trains, aircraft and construction activities, the noise from wind turbines is relatively low. Outside the nearest houses, which are at least half a mile away, and more often further, the sound of a wind turbine generating electricity is likely to be about the same level as noise of leaves rustling in a gentle breeze. This is similar to the sound level inside a typical living room with a gas fire switched on, or the reading room of a library or in an unoccupied, quiet, air-conditioned office.
Source/Activity Indicative noise level dB (A)
Threshold of hearing 0
Rural night-time background 20-40
Quiet bedroom 35
Wind farm at 350m 35-45
Car at 40mph at 100m 55
Busy general office 60
Truck at 30mph at 100m 65
Pneumatic drill at 7m 95
Jet aircraft at 250m 105
Threshold of pain 140
Table 2.1 Comparative noise levels
There are two potential sources of noise related to wind turbines: the turbine blades passing through the air as the hub rotates, and the gearbox and generator in the nacelle. Noise from the blades is minimised by careful attention to the design and manufacture of the blades. The noise from the gearbox and generator is contained within the nacelle by sound insulation and isolation materials. Preliminary recommendations from the Wind Turbine Noise Working Group, established by the DTI in the UK, are that turbine noise level should be kept to within 5 dB(A) of the average existing evening or night-time background noise level. A fixed low level of between 35 and 40 dB(A) may be specified when background noise is very low, ie. Less than 30 dB(A).
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
35
Wind Energy
b. Bird-kill This is a very emotionally charged subject. Bird conservationists tend to view wind turbines as death machines and refer to bloody bird corpses lying at the foot of turbine towers and entire species migrating from the areas surrounding wind farms. Birds occasionally collide with wind turbines, as they do with other tall structures such as buildings. Detailed studies and monitoring following construction, at wind development areas indicate that this is a site-specific issue that will not be a problem at most potential wind sites. Also, wind's overall impact on birds is low compared with other human-related sources of avian mortality. See Figure 2.4
Figure 2.4 Causes of Bird-kill
the globally networked management school www.msm.nl
Don’t miss the train. Take the Shanghai Express @ MSM
If you already have your Bachelor’s degree, and want to gain an international
outlook, you should discover MSM’s Master of Science in Management
in International Business. You can complete it in one year, with a one month
attachment in Shanghai, China.
Why don't you give your career a boost and chek out our website www.msm.nl
For more info please contact [emailprotected]
Boost your Career in Less Than 1 Year
Ple
ase
clic
k th
e ad
vert
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
36
Wind Energy
c. Visual impacts Wind turbines are just normal structures to look at, just like trees, better looking than boiler chimneys. In comparison to other energy developments, such as nuclear, coal and gas power stations or open cast coal mining, wind farms have relatively little visual impact. Wind farm developers recognise that visual impact can be a concern for neighbouring communities. Considerable effort is therefore committed to the planning stages in order to reduce the impact and gain their consent. A number of national wind energy associations have established detailed best practice guidelines for the development of wind farms, including their visual impact. Surveys of public opinion show that most people who live near wind developments find them less intrusive once they are operating than they might have feared beforehand. Other surveys, for instance in Scotland, have shown that there is no evidence that tourism is seriously affected by the presence of wind farms. The authors experience is the opposite to that, I found myself going to places never thought I would, for the simple reason to see how the wind turbines work and enjoy the view of clean energy machine. Although a wind energy project can spread across a large total land area, it does not occupy all that space. Farming or leisure activities can still continue around the turbines. The European Wind Energy Association has estimated that the number of wind farms required to contribute 20% of Europe’s electricity supply would take up only a few hundred square kilometres. d. Shadow Flicker is occasionally raised as an issue by some people. A wind turbine's moving blades can cast a moving shadow on a nearby residence, depending on the time of the year (which determines how low the sun is in the sky) and time of day. It is possible to calculate very precisely whether a flickering shadow will in fact fall on a given location near a wind farm, and how many hours in a year it will do so. Therefore, it should be easy to determine whether this is a potential problem. e. Communication interference Wind turbines, like all structures, can interfere with communication or radar signals when these signals are interrupted by the turbine structure or the rotor plane. Wind turbines can sometimes cause electromagnetic interference affecting TV and radio reception. Electromagnetic interference can be caused by near-field effects, diffraction, or reflection and scattering. Such interference can typically be mitigated by using satellite TV or wireless cable TV. Although instances of TV or radio interference are infrequent and typically straightforward to mitigate, the interaction of wind turbines and navigational or defence radar signals is the subject of considerable recent attention
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
37
Wind Energy
A number of tools and practices are available to manage or mitigate the potential impact of wind turbine interference:
Farm layout optimization, terrain masking, or reduction of the radar cross-section area may be sufficient to address identified interference problems.
Coating equipment with absorbent or reflective materials to minimize the turbine's radar signature.
Often the easiest and least costly approaches involve software optimization. Other options include
installing post-processors or adding hardware (such as processors, transmitters, or receivers). When such changes alone are insufficient, more involved approaches can sometimes be implemented. These include deploying extra radars to cover the shadow spots, relocating radar installations to accommodate the new wind farms, or altering air traffic routes around new wind farms.
Even with these mitigation methods, there will be some proposed locations where wind turbines will cause disruptive radar interference. In such cases, wind projects would likely be unable to proceed at the proposed site.
Figure 2.5 “Not” a perfect place to site a wind farm.
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
38
Theory of Wind Energy
3 Theory of Wind Energy The principles concerned with converting the potential energy of fluids into useful power relies on three basic fundamentals: conservation of mass, energy and momentum, so it is useful to discuss these before examining the operation of wind turbines.
3.1 Conservation of Mass: The continuity equation applies the principle of conservation of mass to fluid flow. Consider a fluid flowing through a fixed conduit having one inlet and one outlet as shown in Figure 3.1
Figure 3.1 Conservation of mass of a fluid flowing in a duct/pipe
www.job.oticon.dk
Ple
ase
clic
k th
e ad
vert
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
39
Theory of Wind Energy
If the flow is steady i.e no accumulation of fluid within the control volume, then the rate of fluid flow at entry must be equal to the rate of fluid flow at exit for mass conservation. If the flow cross-sectional area A (m2), and the fluid parcel travels a distance dL in time dt, then the volume flow rate (Vf, m3/s) is given by:
dt/dL.AVf but since dL/dt is the fluid velocity (V, m/s) we can write: Vf = V x A
The mass flow rate (m, kg/s) is given by the product of density and volume flow rate. Between any two points within the control volume, the fluid mass flow rate can be shown to remain constant: or 222111 VAVA (1)
3.2 Conservation of Energy: Conservation of energy necessitates that the total energy of the fluid remains constant, however, there can be transformation from one form to another. There are three forms of non-thermal energy for a fluid at any given point:- The kinetic energy due to the motion of the fluid. The potential energy due to the positional elevation above a datum. The pressure energy, due to the absolute pressure of the fluid at that point. If all energy terms are written in the form of the head (potential energy), ie in metres of the fluid, then conservation of energy principle requires that:
2
2
1
2
z2gV
gpz
2gV
gp
(2a)
This equation is known as the Bernoulli equation and is valid if the two points of interest 1 & 2 are very close to each other and there is no loss of energy. In a real situation, the flow will suffer a loss of energy due to friction (hL) and obstruction between stations 1 & 2, hence
L2
2
1
2
hz2gV
gpz
2gV
gp
(2b)
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
40
Theory of Wind Energy
3.3 Conservation of Momentum
Consider a duct of length L, cross-sectional area Ac, surface area As, in which a fluid of density, is flowing at mean velocity V. The forces acting on a segment of the duct are that due to pressure difference and that due to friction at the walls in contact with the fluid. If the acceleration of the fluid is zero, the net forces acting on the element must be zero, hence
(p1 - p2). Ac - (f V2/2). As= 0
or p1 - p2 = g hf
where hf = f. (As/Ac). V2/2g For a pipe As/Ac = D L / D2/4 = 4L/D hence hf = (4 fL/D). V2/2g (3) This is known as Darcy formula.
The value of the friction factor (f) depends mainly on two parameters namely the value of the Reynolds number and the surface roughness. The Reynolds number is defined in terms of the density, velocity of flow, diameter and the dynamic viscosity as follows:
.V.DRe (4)
For laminar flow (ie Re < 2000),
Re16f (5a)
While for a smooth pipe with turbulent (i.e. Re > 4000) flow,
0.25Re0.079f (5b)
For Re > 2000 and Re < 4000, this region is known as the critical zone and the value of the friction factor is certain.
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
41
Theory of Wind Energy
In the turbulent zone, if the surface of the pipe is not perfectly smooth, then the value of the friction factor has to be determined from the Moody diagram (see overleaf). The relative roughness is the ratio of the average height of the surface projections on the inside of the pipe (k) to the pipe diameter (D). In common with Reynolds number and friction factor this parameter is dimensionless.
3.4 Ideal Wind Power calculations: In Theory, Wind power (P) is calculated by the following general equation (the proof for which will be derived in the following section):
3p V*A*
21*CP (6)
Where Cp is the power coefficient is the density of the oncoming air A swept area of the rotor V is the velocity of the wind The actual power is further reduced by two more inefficiencies, due to the gear box losses and the generator efficiency.
At NNE Pharmaplan we need ambitious people to help us achieve the challenging goals which have been laid down for the company.
Kim Visby is an example of one of our many ambitious co-workers. Besides being a manager in the Manufacturing IT department, Kim performs triathlon at a professional level.
‘NNE Pharmaplan offers me freedom with responsibility as well as the opportunity to plan my own time. This enables me to perform triath-lon at a competitive level, something I would not have the possibility of doing otherwise.’
‘By balancing my work and personal life, I obtain the energy to perform my best, both at work and in triathlon.’
If you are ambitious and want to join our world of opportunities, go to nnepharmaplan.com
NNE Pharmaplan is the world’s leading engineering and consultancy company focused exclusively on the pharma and biotech industries. NNE Pharmaplan is a company in the Novo Group.
wanted: ambitious people
Ple
ase
clic
k th
e ad
vert
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
42
Theory of Wind Energy
The value of the ideal power is limited by what is know as Betz coefficient with a value of Cp = 0.59 as the highest possible conversion efficiency possible. In practice, most wind turbines have efficiencies well below 0.5, depending on the type, design and operational conditions. In the operational output range, wind power generated increases with wind speed cubed. In other words, at a wind speed of 5 m/s, the power output is proportional with 5 cubed = 125, whereas at a wind speed of 10 m/s, the power output is proportional to 1000. This shows that doubling the speed from 5 to 10 m/s resulted in a power increase of 8 folds. This highlights the importance of location when it comes to install wind turbines. The effect of the rotor diameter affect the power output in a square manner, i.e, doubling the rotor diameter results in increasing the power output by four times. On the other hand, since power generated is related to wind speed by a cubic ratio. That means if your turbine is rated at producing 1KW at 12m/s then it will produce 125W at 6m/s and 15W at 3m/s. 3.3.1 Theory of Wind Turbines A windmill extracts power from the wind by slowing down the wind. At stand still, the rotor obviously produces no power, and at very high rotational speeds the air is more or less blocked by the rotor, and again no power is produced.
Figure 3.2 Ideal Wind Energy Theory. The Power produced (Pkin) by the wind turbine is the net kinetic energy change across the wind turbine (from initial air velocity of V1 to a turbine exit air velocity of V2) is given as:
]VV[xm21P 2
22
1kin (7)
The mass flow rate of wind is given by the continuity equation as the product of density, area swept by the turbine rotor and the approach air velocity as:
aV*A*m (8)
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
43
Theory of Wind Energy
Hence the power becomes:
]VV[*V*A*x21P 2
22
1akin (9)
Since the rotor speed is the average speed (Va) between inlet and outlet:
]VV[21V 21a (10)
Hence, the power is Pkin =(1/2)** A * (V1+V2)/2) * [(V1)2 - (V2)2] =(1/4)** A * [V1
3 - V23 - V1* V2
2 + V12 * V2) ]
=(1/4)** A * V13*[1- (V2/V1)
3– (V2/V1) 2 + (V2/V1)
] (11) To find the maximum power extracted by the rotor, differentiate equation 11 with respect to V2 and equate it to zero dPkin / dV2 = 1/4 * * A * (-3 * V2
2 - 2 * V1* V2 + V12) = 0 (12)
Since the area of the rotor (A) and the density of the air (r) cannot be zero, the expression in the bracket of equation 12 has to be zero. Hence, the quadratic equation becomes:
0)VV)(VV3( 1212 Since V2 = - V1 is unrealistic in this situation, there is only one solution, equation 12 yields:
12 V31V (13)
Substitution of equation 13 into equation 11 results in:
]V*A*[21*)5925.0(P 3
1kin (14)
The theoretical maximum fraction of the power in the wind which could be extracted by an ideal windmill is, therefore the fraction 0.5925 is called the Betz Coefficient. Because of aerodynamic imperfections in any practical machine and of mechanical loses, the power extracted is less than that calculated above. Figure 3.7 demonstrates the effect of wind turbine design implications on the resulting power that can be harnessed from the incoming wind. Efficient wind turbines depend on the production of that optimum speed ratio giving the maximum or near the maximum power possible.
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
44
Theory of Wind Energy
Equation 14 clearly shows that:
The power is proportional to the density () of the air which varies slightly with altitude and temperature
The power is proportional to the area (A) swept by the blades and thus to the square of the radius (R) of the rotor; and
the power varies with the cube of the wind speed (V3). This means that the power increases eightfold if the wind speed is doubled. Hence, one has to pay particular attention in site selection.
3.3.2 Distinction between rated and actual power output of the turbine The world's largest wind turbine generator has a rotor blade diameter of 126 metres and is located on offshore, at sea-level and so we know the air density is 1.2 kg/m3. The turbine is rated at 5MW in 30mph (14m/s) winds, Rotor Swept area A= (. 1262)/4 = 12469 m2 Wind Power = 0.5 x A x x V3 = 0.5x12469x 1.2 x (14)3 = 20.5 MW
Ple
ase
clic
k th
e ad
vert
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
45
Theory of Wind Energy
Why is the power of the wind (20MW) so much larger than the rated power of the turbine generator (5MW)? The answer lies in the fact that the Betz limit and inefficiencies in the system seriously absorbs over 60% of the apparent power. There are two further factors to be considered when estimating the power output from a turbine, the first is the mechanical transmission and the second is the generator’s efficiency, both of which are less than unity, hence the real power is proportionately less than the ideal value. The capacity factor, Cf. Assuming a 5 kW wind turbine generates annually 10 MWh, if that same installation had run – theoretically – 24 hours a day and 365 days a year at full load, it would have generated 43.8 MWh. The capacity factor (Cf) is 10/43.8 = 0.23. Typical values for Cf between 0.2 and 0.4 in the united kingdom, depending on the exact location.
Betz Limit
00.10.20.30.40.50.60.7
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2
V2/V1
Cp
Figure 3.3 Betz Limit on wind energy efficiency and its Implications.
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
46
Wind Turbines types and components
4 Wind Turbines types and components
4.1 Types of Wind Turbines There are mainly two types of wind turbine: horizontal axis and vertical axis. The horizontal axis wind turbine (HAWT) and the vertical axis wind turbine (VAWT) are classified or differentiated by the axis of rotation the rotor shafts.
Horizontal Axis Wind Turbines - Horizontal axis wind turbines, also known as HAWT type turbines have a horizontal rotor shaft and an electrical generator which is both located at the top of a tower.
Vertical Axis Wind Turbines - abbreviated as VAWTs, are designed with a vertical rotor shaft, a generator and gearbox which are placed at the bottom of the turbine, and a uniquely shaped rotor blade that is designed to harvest the power of the wind no matter which direction is it blowing. The first is the Darrieus wind turbine, which is designed to look like a modified egg beater. These turbines have very good efficiency, but poor reliability due to the massive amount of torque which they exert on the frame. Furthermore, they also require a small generator to get them started.
SavoniusVAWT
HelicalVAWT
Darrieus VAWT
3-bladesHAWT
2 bladesHAWT
Figure 4.1 Wind Turbines, Some types
http://www.educypedia.be/education/
4.2 Components of a Wind Turbine Wind turbine usually has six main components: the rotor, the gearbox, the generator, the control and protection system, the tower and the foundation. These main components can be seen in figure 4.2.
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
47
Wind Turbines types and components
Figure 4.2 Wind Turbine components
Courtesy of National Instruments Corporation, USA.
By 2020, wind could provide one-tenth of our planet’s electricity needs. Already today, SKF’s innovative know-how is crucial to running a large proportion of the world’s wind turbines.
Up to 25 % of the generating costs relate to mainte-nance. These can be reduced dramatically thanks to our systems for on-line condition monitoring and automatic lubrication. We help make it more economical to create cleaner, cheaper energy out of thin air.
By sharing our experience, expertise, and creativity, industries can boost performance beyond expectations.
Therefore we need the best employees who can meet this challenge!
The Power of Knowledge Engineering
Brain power
Plug into The Power of Knowledge Engineering.
Visit us at www.skf.com/knowledge
Ple
ase
clic
k th
e ad
vert
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
48
Wind Turbines types and components
Rotor - The rotor is an elegant aerofoil shaped blades which take the wind and aerodynamically converts its kinetic energy into mechanical energy through a connected shaft. Gearbox - The gearbox alters the rotational velocity of the shaft to suit the generator. Generator - The generator is a device that produces electricity when mechanical work is given to the system. Control and Protection System - The protection system is like a safety feature that makes sure that the turbine will not be working under dangerous condition. This includes a brake system triggered by the signal of higher wind speeds to stop the rotor from movement under excessive wind gusts. Tower - The tower is the main shaft that connects the rotor to the foundation. It also raises the rotor high in the air where we can find stronger winds. With horizontal axis wind turbines, the tower houses the stairs to allow for maintenance and inspection. Foundation - The foundation or the base supports the entire wind turbine and make sure that it is well fixed onto the ground or the roof for small household wind turbines. This is usually consists of a solid concrete assembly around the tower to maintain its structural integrity. In addition to the main components of a wind turbine, a wind energy generation system is shown in Figure 4.2, incorporating a charge controller, Battery and inverter so that the electricity is converted for use by house appliances and lights.
Figure 4.3 Wind Energy System
http://www.inverter-china.com/
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
49
Wind Turbines types and components
4.3 Relationship between Wind speed and Rotor speed The Tip Speed Ratio - (often known as the tsr) is of vital importance in the design of wind turbine generators. If the rotor of the wind turbine turns too slowly, most of the wind will pass undisturbed through the gap between the rotor blades. Conversely if the rotor turns too quickly, the blurring blades will appear like a solid wall to the wind. Therefore, wind turbines are designed with optimal tip speed ratios to extract as much power out of the wind as possible. The optimum tip speed ratio depends on the number of blades in the wind turbine rotor. The fewer the number of blades, the faster the wind turbine rotor needs to turn to extract maximum power from the wind. A two-bladed rotor has an optimum tip speed ratio of around 6, a three-bladed rotor around 5, and a four-bladed rotor around 3. Figure 4.4 show some of the common Wind turbines and their respective efficiency against tip speed ratio (tsr).
Figure 4.4 Typical Wind turbine efficiencies
Courtesy of http://www.windturbine-analysis.netfirms.com/
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
50
Wind Energy Measurements
5 Wind Energy Measurements There are four measurements associated with wind energy, the measurements of electrical signals including voltage, current or collectively electrical power, wind turbine rotational speed and the wind speed.
5.1 Electrical measurements In order to determine electrical energy output, it is necessary to be able to measure it either directly as energy in kWh, or indirectly by measuring the voltage, current of the generated output of the wind turbine.
Quantity Symbol Unit of measurement
Unit abb.
Current I Amp A
Voltage V Volt V
Resistance R Ohm
Power/Energy E Watt W
Table 5.1 Electrical Measurements
We have ambitions. Also for you.
SimCorp is a global leader in financial software. At SimCorp, you will be part of a large network of competent
and skilled colleagues who all aspire to reach common goals with dedication and team spirit. We invest in our
employees to ensure that you can meet your ambitions on a personal as well as on a professional level. SimCorp
employs the best qualified people within economics, finance and IT, and the majority of our colleagues have a
university or business degree within these fields.
Ambitious? Look for opportunities at www.simcorp.com/careers
www.simcorp.com
Ple
ase
clic
k th
e ad
vert
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
51
Wind Energy Measurements
5.1.1 Ohms Law Ohm's law states that the current (I) through a conductor between two points is proportional to the potential difference (V) and inversely proportional to the resistance (R).
V = I. R (15)
Figure 5.1 Ohms Law
5.1.2 Electrical Power Electrical power (E) is the amount of energy produced. The unit of measurement of Power being the Watt (W) with prefixes used to denote milliwatts (mW = 10-3W) or kilowatts (kW = 103W). By using Ohm's law and substituting for V (volts) , I (amps) and R (Ω)the formula for electrical power, E (watts) can be found as: E = V x I (16a) E = V2 ÷ R (16b) E = I2 x R (16c) 5.1.3 Alternating Current Power As in the case with DC power, the instantaneous electric power in an AC circuit is given by E = VI, (17) But these quantities are continuously varying. Almost always the desired power in an AC circuit is the average power, which is given by Eavg = VI cosφ (18)
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
52
Wind Energy Measurements
Where φ is the phase angle between the current and the voltage and where V and I are understood to be the effective or rms values of the voltage and current, see Figure 5.2. The term cos φ is called the "power factor" for the circuit, a power factor of one or "unity power factor" is the goal of any electric utility company since if the power factor is less than one, they have to supply more current to the user for a given amount of power use. In so doing, they incur more line losses. They also must have larger capacity equipment in place than would be otherwise necessary.
Figure 5.2 Resistive AC circuit The difference between the maximum and minimum values is called peak-to-peak voltage (Vpp) and is twice the peak Voltage (Vp). The RMS voltage. (Vrms) is related to the peak voltage as: Vrms = 0,707 x Vp. (19) Circuit currents and voltages in AC circuits are generally stated as root-mean-square or rms values rather than by quoting the maximum values. The root-mean-square for a current is defined by
averms II 2 (20)
That is, you take the square of the current and average it, then take the square root. When this process is carried out for a sinusoidal current
2III
hence2
I)]t.(sin*I[
mave
2rms
2m
ave22
m
(21)
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
53
Wind Energy Measurements
Since the AC voltage is also sinusoidal, the form of the rms voltage is the same. These rms values are just the effective value needed in the expression for average power:
)cos(*I*V)cos(*2
I*VEav rmsrmsmm (22)
Since the voltage and current are both sinusoidal, the power expression can be expressed in terms of the squares of sine or cosine functions, and the average of a sine or cosine squared over a whole period is = 1/2. 5.1.4 Electrical Measurements Energy related measurements concerned with electricity production and consumption are usually derived from three elements namely: the electrical current, voltage and resistance of the load. These three variables are directly linked with the energy or power consumption of the load and hence it is common to see a single meter combining these to give a direct reading of the energy consumption. Multimeters are very useful test instruments. By operating a multi-position switch on the meter they can be quickly and easily set to be a voltmeter, an ammeter or an ohmmeter. Two devices can be used to measure the electrical measurements: analog and digital multimeters as shown below in Figure. 5.3.
what‘s missing in this equation?
maeRsK inteRnationaL teChnoLogY & sCienCe PRogRamme
You could be one of our future talents
Are you about to graduate as an engineer or geoscientist? Or have you already graduated?If so, there may be an exciting future for you with A.P. Moller - Maersk.
www.maersk.com/mitas
Ple
ase
clic
k th
e ad
vert
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
54
Wind Energy Measurements
Figure 5.3 Digital and Analog Multimeters
Courtesy of http://www.kpsec.freeuk.com/multimtr.htm As far as power is concerned, the most common unit of power consumption measurement on the electricity meter is the kilowatt hour, which is equal to the amount of energy used by a load of one kilowatt over a period of one hour, or 3,600,000 joules. Some electricity companies use the SI mega joule instead. Modern electricity meters operate by continuously measuring the instantaneous voltage (volts) and current (amperes) and finding the product of these to give instantaneous electrical power (watts) which is then integrated against time to give energy used (joules, kilowatt-hours etc). The meters fall into two basic categories, electromechanical and electronic, as shown in Figure. 5.4. The mechanical electricity meter has every other dial rotating counter-clockwise. The most common type of electricity meter is the Thomson or electromechanical induction watt-hour meter, invented by Elihu Thomson in 1888. it work by counting the revolutions of an aluminium disc which is made to rotate at a speed proportional to the power. The metallic disc is acted upon by two coils. One coil is connected in such a way that it produces a magnetic flux in proportion to the voltage and the other produces a magnetic flux in proportion to the current. A modern digital electronic wattmeter/energy meter samples the voltage and current thousands of times a second. The average of the instantaneous voltage multiplied by the current is the true power. The true power divided by the apparent volt-amperes (VA) is the power factor. A computer circuit uses the sampled values to calculate RMS voltage, RMS current, VA, power (watts), power factor, and kilowatt-hours. The simple models display that information on LCD. More sophisticated models retain the information over an extended period of time, and can transmit it to field equipment or a central location.
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
55
Wind Energy Measurements
Figure 5.4 Measurement of Power
Courtesy of http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/
5.2 Velocity and flow measured by Anemometers Wind speed is the most important factor directly proportional to the power output of a wind turbine. Various types of anemometer are used to measure the velocity, usually of air. 5.2.1 The ‘cup type’ air speed measurement (Figure 5.5) is used for free air and has hemispherical cups on arms attached to a rotating shaft. The shape of the cups gives a greater drag on one side than the other and results in a speed of rotation approximately proportional to the air speed. Velocity is found by measuring revolutions over a fixed time.
Figure 5.5 Cup Type Anemometer 5.2.2 The ‘vane anemometer’ (Figure 5.6) has an axial impeller attached to a handle with extensions and an electrical pick-up which measures the revolutions. A meter with several ranges indicates the velocity.
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
56
Wind Energy Measurements
Figure 5.6 Vane Anemometer
Ple
ase
clic
k th
e ad
vert
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
57
Wind Energy Measurements
5.2.3 The ‘hot-wire’ anemometer’ (Figure 5.7) is a probe terminating in an extremely small heated wire element when subjected to a fluid stream it cools to an extent, which depends on the velocity of the fluid passing. The resulting change in resistance of the element is measured by a bridge circuit and is related to velocity by calibration.
Figure 5.7 Hot-Wire Anemometer
5.3 Measurement of speed of rotation The following methods are used to measure the speed of rotation of an object: -
Mechanical Tachometer Digital Tachometer Stroboscopes Magnetic Field Angular Position Sensors Wheel Encoder
The choice of technique used for measurement is governed by the application range considered, degree of accuracy required, type of installation and original cost. In this section each type will be discussed and an overview of the importance of time measurement will also be discussed. 5.3.1 Mechanical Tachometer This type of tachometer is a linkage of shafts, gears and rotating weights. When the input shaft which is seen horizontal rotates the vertical shaft it also rotates the weights attached to it which are hinged and free to move inward and outwards. The movement of these flyweights rotates a pointer which is calibrated to give the speed in desired units such as RPM. Two main drawbacks of this are that the mechanical weights have inertia and hence not very accurate and secondly it does not give an indication of the direction of rotation.
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
58
Wind Energy Measurements
Figure 5.8 Mechanical Tachometer
Courtesy of http://www.brighthub.com/ 5.3.2 Electrical Tachometers This type of tachometer could be as simple as a DC or AC generator that can determine the speed of shaft rotation by the amount of voltage the generator produces or the frequency of the output signal. The magnitude of the generator voltage and the frequency of the generated voltage will increase proportionally with speed. Frequency can also be measured by a photocell tachometer. The number of pulses produced by the photocell will increase as the speed of the shaft rotation increases. The rotating field and the toothed rotor tachometers produce a waveform and the photocell uses a rotating disk that has a number of windows in it. A light source is positioned so that it will shine light through each window in the disk to a photocell detector as the disk spins. The disk is connected to the tachometer shaft, so when it turns the windows line up with the photocell and the photocell produces a pulse when it is struck by light. In each of these types of tachometers a pulse stream is produced and it is proportional to the speed of the tachometer shaft.
Figure 5.9 Digital Tachometer
Courtesy of http://www.vaiseshika.com/
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
59
Wind Energy Measurements
5.3.3 Stroboscope Also known as the “strobe”, is an instrument used to make a cyclically moving object appear to be slow-moving, or stationary. The principle is used for the study of rotating, reciprocating, oscillating or vibrating objects. Machine parts and vibrating strings are common examples. In electronic versions, the perforated disc is replaced by a lamp capable of emitting brief and rapid flashes of light. The frequency of the flash is adjusted so that it is an equal to, or a unit fraction below or above the object's cyclic speed, at which point the object is seen to be either stationary or moving backward or forward, depending on the flash frequency.
Figure 5.10 Stroboscope
Courtesy of http://www.accesscontrolsales.com/ In order to make a measurement, a mark is made on the object when it is stationary, and the object is spun up to speed. The oscillator is set to a low frequency to start with, and the LED is shone at the object where the mark is. At first, the mark will appear at random points around the object When it is stationary, the LED is flashing at the same frequency as the object is rotating. Since the frequency is known, the rotational speed is also known, and can be stated in RPM using the formula: RPM = 60 x fstrobe 5.3.4 Magnetic Field Angular Position Sensors These are similar shaft encoders, with one exception. They are capable of measuring the angle direction of a magnetic field from a magnet with <0.07° resolution. The advantages of measuring field direction versus field strength include: insensitivity to the temperature coefficient of the magnet, less sensitivity to shock and vibration, and the ability to withstand large variations in the gap between the sensor and magnet. These sensors may be operated below 3 volts with a bandwidth response of 0-5 MHz. Output is a typical Wheatstone bridge permitting balanced output signals for noise immunity.
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
60
Wind Energy Measurements
The main application of this sensor is to determine the angular position of a rotary axis. In this case, a permanent magnet is fixed on the engine axis just above the sensor. This magnet generates a directional magnetic field parallel to the surface of the sensor (Figure 5.11). This field works as a contactless interface between the orientation of the axis and the sensor.
Figure 5.11 The permanent magnet speed sensor.
it’s an interesting world
Where it’sStudent and Graduate opportunities in IT, Internet & EngineeringCheltenham | £competitive + benefits
Part of the UK’s intelligence services, our role is to counter threats that compromise national and globalsecurity. We work in one of the most diverse, creative and technically challenging IT cultures. Throw incontinuous professional development, and you get truly interesting work, in a genuinely inspirational business.
To find out more visit www.careersinbritishintelligence.co.uk
Applicants must be British citizens. GCHQ values diversity and welcomes applicants from all sections of the community. We want our workforce to reflect the diversity of our work.
Ple
ase
clic
k th
e ad
vert
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
61
Wind Energy Measurements
5.3.5 Wheel encoder Figure 5.12 shows an example of a typical encoder wheel. The resolution of the encoder wheel is determine by the number of cycles or complete phases.
Figure 5.12 Wheel Encoder The encoder is a sensor attached to a rotating object (such as a wheel or motor) to measure rotation. A typical encoder uses optical sensor(s), a moving mechanical component, and a special reflector to provide a series of electrical pulses. These pulses can be used as part of a feedback control system to determine translation distance, rotational velocity of a rotating component. For instance, to measure the time it takes motor to rotate exactly 360 degrees or more or less, an encoder would be ideal. The sensor would be fixed on the shaft (the encoder wheel) would rotate with the shaft. The output of an encoder would be a square wave, so if you hook up this signal to a digital counter or microcontroller you can then count the pulses. Knowing the distance/angle between each pulse, and the time from start to finish, you can easily determine position or angle or velocity of the motor.
5.4 The importance of speed in Turbine’s measurements it was discussed earlier that the power output of a wind turbine is proportional the cube of the speed. The speed is the most important parameter in evaluating the power from a turbine. It is often understated by manufacturers or misunderstood by buyers that the power rating of a wind turbine is only true at a given speed, know as the rated speed, which is neither too loo nor too high, but somewhere where it is trusted that the wind turbine will be able to withstand the forces of rotation. These speeds are distinguished into four different regimes (Figure 5.13):
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
62
Wind Energy Measurements
a. Start-up Speed – This is the speed at which the rotor and blade assembly begins to rotate. b. Cut-in Speed – Cut-in speed is the minimum wind speed at which the wind turbine will generate usable power. This wind speed is typically between 7 and 10 mph for most turbines. c. Rated Speed – The rated speed is the minimum wind speed at which the wind turbine will generate its designated rated power. For example, a "10 kilowatt" wind turbine may not generate 10 kilowatts until wind speeds reach 25 mph. Rated speed for most machines is in the range of 25 to 35 mph. At wind speeds between cut-in and rated, the power output from a wind turbine increases as the wind increases. The output of most machines levels off above the rated speed. Most manufacturers provide graphs, called "power curves," showing how their wind turbine output varies with wind speed. d. Cut-out Speed – At very high wind speeds, typically between 45 and 80 mph, most wind turbines cease power generation and shut down. The wind speed at which shut down occurs is called the cut-out speed, or sometimes the furling speed. Having a cut-out speed is a safety feature which protects the wind turbine from damage. Shut down may occur in one of several ways. In some machines an automatic brake is activated by a wind speed sensor. Some machines twist or "pitch" the blades to spill the wind. Still others use "spoilers," drag flaps mounted on the blades or the hub which are automatically activated by high rotor rpm's, or mechanically activated by a spring loaded device which turns the machine sideways to the wind stream. Normal wind turbine operation usually resumes when the wind drops back to a safe level.
Figure 5.13 Wind speeds for a wind turbine
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
63
Worked Examples
6 Worked Examples Worked Example 6.1
The table below summarises the data for a wind turbine to be installed. Determine the annual power output for this turbine on this particular site.
Set Wind Speed (m/sec)
Turbine Output (kW)
No of hours per year at given wind speed
(a) (b) (c) (d)
1 4 2 1100
2 5 4 1100
3 6 6 1000
4 7 8 900
5 8 10 800
6 9 10 600
7 10 10 400
8 11 10 300
9 12 10 200
10 13 10 100
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
64
Worked Examples
Solution: First calculate the power output for each speed group, and then add them up as shown below. Hence the annual output is calculated as 43.8 MWh per year
Set Wind Speed (m/sec)
Turbine Output (kW)
No of hours per year at given wind speed
Power output kWh (c x d)
(a) (b) (c) (d) (e)
1 4 2 1100 2200
2 5 4 1100 4400
3 6 6 1000 6000
4 7 8 900 7200
5 8 10 800 8000
6 9 10 600 6000
7 10 10 400 4000
8 11 10 300 3000
9 12 10 200 2000
10 13 10 100 1000
43800
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
65
Worked Examples
Worked Example 6.2 If the average wind speed of 10 mph which yields 100 watts per square meter, Determine the power produced by a wind mill when the wind speed is 40 mph.
Ple
ase
clic
k th
e ad
vert
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
66
Worked Examples
Solution: The change in wind speed means that wind blows at the ratio of (40/10 = 4 ) times Since the power is proportional to wind speed to power 3, Hence an increase in wind velocity of 4 times, implies that the power will be increased by a factor of: 43 = 64 Therefore, if a 10 mph wind gives you 100 watts Then a 40 mph wind gives you 64 times more power
=64x100 = 6400 watts = 6.4 kW.
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
67
Worked Examples
Worked Example 6.3 The following specifications for two HAWT are supplied by the manufacturers.
Item Turbine A Turbine B
Rotor diameter 25m 28m
Power coefficient 38 35
Gearbox efficiency 90 88
Generator efficiency 98 95
Capital cost £99,000 £103,000
Maintenance cost/year £4,000 £4,000
a. draw up a table for the performance of each turbine for wind speeds 4-12 m/s in intervals of 2 m/s b. Assume the site wind availability to be 2000 hours per year, and average wind speed of 6 m/s,
select the wind turbine which will be most economical. Assume life expectancy for each to be 20 years, and the unit cost of power to be 6 pence per kWh to remain constant.
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
68
Worked Examples
Solution: (a)The shaft power of a wind rotor is given by: P = Cp * 1/2 * * A* V3 *gb *gen
Wind speed m/s
Turbine A Power (kW)=98.713V3
Turbine B Power(kW)=108.101V3
4 6.317 6.918
6 21.322 23.350
8 50.541 55.348
10 98.713 108.101
12 170.576 186.799
(b) at 6 m/s, Turbine B, produce more power The annual difference = (23.350-21.322)x2000 = 4056 kWh Cost difference over 20 years = 4056x0.06x20 = £4867 Hence Turbine B is chosen even though it is £4000 more expensive to buy than A, with a net saving of £867.
In Paris or OnlineInternational programs taught by professors and professionals from all over the world
BBA in Global BusinessMBA in International Management / International MarketingDBA in International Business / International ManagementMA in International EducationMA in Cross-Cultural CommunicationMA in Foreign Languages
Innovative – Practical – Flexible – Affordable
Visit: www.HorizonsUniversity.orgWrite: [emailprotected]: 01.42.77.20.66 www.HorizonsUniversity.org
Ple
ase
clic
k th
e ad
vert
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
69
Worked Examples
Worked Example 6.4
In order to study the relationship between the current (I), voltage (V) and resistance (R) as related by Ohms law, see the circuit below; calculate:
a. The current (I) in the circuit shown below, for given values of voltage (V=12v) and resistance
(R=3 ohm)
b. The resistance (R) in a circuit, given values of voltage (V=24v) and current (I=4Amps)
c. The voltage supplied by a battery, given values of current (I=2 Amps) and resistance (R=6
ohms). Determine the power consumption of the lamp in this case.
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
70
Worked Examples
Solution:
a. Using Ohms Law, the current:
Amps43
12RVI
b. The resistance in the circuit is
64
24IVR
c. The voltage provided by the battery is:
Volts126x2IxRV The power consumption of the lamp is:
E = I2.R = 22 x 6 = 24 Watts
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
71
Worked Examples
Worked Example 6.5
Determine the currents associated in each branch of the circuit shown below, and the power of the battery.
At NNE Pharmaplan we need ambitious people to help us achieve the challenging goals which have been laid down for the company.
Kim Visby is an example of one of our many ambitious co-workers. Besides being a manager in the Manufacturing IT department, Kim performs triathlon at a professional level.
‘NNE Pharmaplan offers me freedom with responsibility as well as the opportunity to plan my own time. This enables me to perform triath-lon at a competitive level, something I would not have the possibility of doing otherwise.’
‘By balancing my work and personal life, I obtain the energy to perform my best, both at work and in triathlon.’
If you are ambitious and want to join our world of opportunities, go to nnepharmaplan.com
NNE Pharmaplan is the world’s leading engineering and consultancy company focused exclusively on the pharma and biotech industries. NNE Pharmaplan is a company in the Novo Group.
wanted: ambitious people
Ple
ase
clic
k th
e ad
vert
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
72
Worked Examples
Solution:
Remember that in parallel branching the voltage in each branch is the same as that in the main battery.
Amps34
12RVI1
Amps26
12RVI2
in parallel branching the current in each branch depends on the resistance of the branch, the total current in the battery is the sum of both currents flowing in each branch. Hence the total current flowing through the battery I=3+2 = 5 Amps. The power of the battery is E = V.I = 12 x 5 = 60 Watts
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
73
Tutorial Problems
7 Tutorial Problems 7.1 Calculate the power delivered by the wind, in watts per square metre, for wind speed over a
range from 1 to 20 metres per second. (Assume the density of air at normal pressure to be 1.23 kg per cubic metre.)
Ans [10W, 1 W, 2 Amps] 7.2 The rotor diameter of a two-bladed HAWT is 7.0 metres. At its rated wind speed of 12.1 metres
per second, the power output of the turbine is 15 kW.
(a) Find the efficiency of the turbine at this wind speed. (The density of air is 1.23 kg per cubic metre.)
(b) Calculate the tip-speed ratio, if the blades are rotating at 240 rpm. Ans [10W, 1 W, 2 Amps]
7.3 A two-bladed horizontal axis wind generator has a rotor diameter of 20 metres.
(a) Operating at a wind speed of 8.1 metres per second, the rotor extracts 35% of the energy of the wind. If the efficiency of the generator which it drives is 85%, find the electrical power output in kilowatts. (The density of air is 1.23 kg per cubic metre.)
(b) The output power of a turbine is equal to the torque exerted by the blades multiplied by the angular velocity (which is approximately 0.1 times the rpm). If the above turbine is rotating at 60 rpm, what is the torque?
Ans [10W, 1 W, 2 Amps] 7.4 A wind Turbine, 3m rotor diameter, produce 1 kW when the average wind speed is 10 m/s.
Determine the power coefficient if the gear box and generator are 100% efficient and the air density is assumed constant as 1.2 kg/m3.
Ans [0.236] 7.5 The total energy input to power stations in the UK in 1990 was 3.05 EJ and the total electrical
output was 300 TWh. The installed generating capacity was 68 GW. (a) Calculate the average energy conversion efficiency of the system. (b) Calculate the maximum possible annual output in TWh, i.e. the output if every power station
had run at full capacity for the entire year.
The actual output expressed as a percentage of this maximum is called the annual load factor of the system. Show that the annual load factor for 1990 was 50%.
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
74
Tutorial Problems
7.6 A coal-fired power station with an output of 660 MW operates at an overall efficiency of 35%. The heat energy released by the burning coal is 28 GJ per tonne.
(a) How many tonnes an hour of coal must be supplied to the plant when it operates at full output? (b) Burning one tonne of coal releases 3.4 tonnes of carbon dioxide. If the above power-station
runs with an average plant load factor of 70%, show that it releases five million tonnes of CO2 a year.
7.7 The rate at which an electrical supply provides energy is equal to its voltage multiplied by the
current which it is supplying. (`Watts equal volts times amps.') (a) A certain 12 V car battery, when fully charged, can supply the equivalent of 1 amp for 40
hours (40 amp-hour rating). Calculate the total energy it can supply, in joules. (b) A car is parked and left with two 25 W headlamp bulbs switched on. If the battery is initially
fully charged, after how many hours will all its stored energy have been used? (c) Electric vehicles use batteries instead of petrol as `portable energy stores'. If an electric car
used the above type of battery, how many would be needed to store the same energy as 40 litres of petrol.
(Assume that the energy content of petrol is 35 MJ per litre.)
7.8 The capital cost of a wind turbine generator is œ20 000, and its operation and maintenance costs
will be œ400 a year. The plant is expected to operate for 25 years. (a) Calculate the present value of the œ400 annual operating and maintenance costs over the 25-
year period, using a discount rate of 10%. Add this to the œ20 000 capital cost to obtain the present value of the total cost.
(b) The generator is expected to supply 28 000 kWh a year for the 25 years. Show that the `present value' of the total output, again discounted at 10% a year, is 254 thousand kWh.
(c) Use the results of (a) and (b) to find the cost of electricity in pence per kWh. 7.9 The rotor diameter of a two-bladed HAWT is 7.0 metres. At its rated wind speed of 12.1 metres
per second, the power output of the turbine is 15 kW. (a) Find the efficiency of the turbine at this wind speed. (The density of air is 1.23 kg per cubic
metre.) (b) Calculate the tip-speed ratio, if the blades are rotating at 240 rpm.
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
75
Tutorial Problems
7.10 A two-bladed horizontal axis wind generator has a rotor diameter of 20 metres.
(a) Operating at a wind speed of 8.1 metres per second, the rotor extracts 35% of the energy of the wind. If the efficiency of the generator which it drives is 85%, find the electrical power output in kilowatts. (The density of air is 1.23 kg per cubic metre.)
(b) The output power of a turbine is equal to the torque exerted by the blades multiplied by the angular velocity (which is approximately 0.1 times the rpm). If the above turbine is rotating at 60 rpm, what is the torque?
7.11 For the circuit shown below find the Voltage V, and the Power P consumed by the load R=12
ohms. What power is needed if the current is doubled?
Ans( 24v, 48W, 192W)
7.12 A string of Christmas tree lights, consisting of twenty lamps, is connected in series across the 240
V mains supply. The power consumption of the whole string is 24 W.
Calculate the resistance of each lamp. Ans (120 ohm)
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
76
Case Study
8 Case Study
8.1 Site Survey of wind energy and wind turbine matching The energy available in a wind stream is a critical element in projecting wind turbine performance and availability at a specific site. In general, availability of power in the wind influences the choice of a wind turbine in terms of the type of configuration, its rotor size and its siting. This study will present a software package especially written using the Microsoft Excel program for Windows, to use the availability of wind energy on a given site under given wind conditions in order to evaluate the pattern and amount of energy possible to collect at any one time. The software package processes the data from a typical wind database, calculates and plots graphs concerning Annual Energy Output (A.E.O.), Power Curves for a range of manufacturers, Wind Speed Frequency, Wind Speed Distribution and Wind Speed Vertical Profile. The package utilises two principles in the calculations namely: The Swept Area Method and the Power Curve Method.
“I have only positive impressions of BI so far. BI provides good quality educationand a broad course portfolio. Many of the courses are based on business cases,which give direct practical skills. The lecturers have solid domestic and international experience which is very inspiring. BI provides various student organisations, whereyou can socialise and gain life time experience”.
Alla Mamonova, Russia, MSc in Business and Economics
BI Norwegian School of Management (BI) offers a wide range of Master of Science (MSc) programmes in:
For more information, visit www.bi.edu/mscBI also offers programmes at Bachelor, Masters, Executive MBA and PhD levels. Visit www.bi.edu for more information.
EFMD
CLICK HEREfor the best
investment in your career
APPLYNOW
LOOKING TO DEVELOP YOUR BUSINESS CAREER?
Ple
ase
clic
k th
e ad
vert
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
77
Case Study
8.2 Introduction Wind energy has been used for thousands of years for milling grain, pumping water, and other mechanical power applications. Today, there are over one million windmills in operation around the world. These are used principally for water pumping and providing electricity for remote regions. On a pan European front, a total of 8,484 MW wind power capacity was installed in the EU in 2008. This puts wind energy ahead of any other power technology for the first time. 36% of all new electricity producing capacity installed in the EU in 2008 was wind energy followed by natural gas (6,932 MW - 29%), oil (2,495 MW - 10%), coal (762 MW - 3%) and hydro (473 MW - 2%).At the end of 2008, there were 65 GW of wind power capacity installed in the EU-27 producing 142 TWh hours of electricity, and meeting 4.2% of EU electricity demand. A binding target of 20% renewable energy has been set for the EU to achieve by 2020 [2]. The UK is the windiest country in Europe, and if utilised effectively it could easily provide power to satisfy the 20% contribution of the UK market. The cost of wind energy equipment fell steadily between the early 1980s and the early 1990s. The technology is continually being improved to make it both cheaper and more reliable, so it can be expected that wind energy will become economically competitive with fossil fuels during the coming decades [3].
8.3 Energy and power in the wind
Kinetic energy of the wind is 2velocity mass 21
(8.1)
If ρ = density of air, V = relative velocity of the wind and A = flow - swept area through which the wind stream passes, then the mass flow rate of air is ρAV. Hence the kinetic energy from equation (8.1) is rewritten as:
Pw = 12
ρ Α V3 (8.2)
Note that this is the ideal power available (Pw), in the wind. Only a fraction of this power can actually be extracted, because of losses that incurred in the energy conversion process. Useful power which can be extracted by the turbine rotor is given by multiplying the available power by a coefficient of performance Cp for the particular turbine. Cp has a maximum theoretical value of 0.593 (Betz’ law). Other losses incurred in conversion through the gearbox and generator.. Thus the actual power output (Pw/t) of a wind turbine rotor is:
Pw/t = Cp η η gen gb
12
ρ Α V3 (8.3)
ηgen = generator efficiency (50% for car alternator, 80% or possibly more for a permanent magnet generator or grid-connected induction generator) ηgb = gearbox / bearings efficiency (depends, could be as high as 95% if good)
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
78
Case Study
The wind variation for a typical site is usually described using the so-called Weibull distribution. The Weibull distribution represents a mathematical distribution which resembles the distribution of different wind speeds throughout the year. It’s a statistical model that gives the probability of occurrence. The basic equation is:
p(U) =
k1 -k
CU exp
CU
Ck
(8.4)
The Rayleigh distribution is a special case of the Weibull distribution in which the shape factor k = 2. Thus the Rayleigh equation is:
p(U) =
2
2
2 v 4 U ð - exp
v 2 U ð
(8.5)
Where v is the annual average wind speed at hub height h above ground level. Wind turbine manufacturers often present performance figures for their machines using the Rayleigh distribution. Figures 8.1, and 8.2 depict two different Rayleigh distributions for two different values of wind speeds (3 and 8 m/s respectively).
Figure 8.1: wind speed v = 3 m/s Figure 8.2: wind speed v = 8 m/s
8.4 Estimating the Annual Energy Output (A.E.O.) wind speed frequency = 8760 x p(U) in [hours/yr] (8.6) Then the wind speed frequency is matching with the power curve to estimate the Annual Energy Output (AEO). Thus:
(AEO) = power x wind speed frequency in [kWh/yr] (8.7)
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
79
Case Study
Finally the total annual energy output (AEO) is calculated by summing the energy produced (kWh/yr) at all wind speeds within the operating range of each wind turbine, and divining by 106 to get results in [GWh/yr]
Total (AEO) = 610(AEO)
in [GWh/yr] (8.8)
8.5 The Software Package The aim of this study is to present a software package especially written using the Microsoft Excel program for Windows. The user is able to use the availability of wind energy on a given site under given wind conditions in order to evaluate the pattern and amount of energy possible to collect at any time during the year. However, this software has the ability to examine any given site throughout the U.K. In this software package there is available a database, of seven (7) different manufacturers and twenty eight (28) different models of various sizes covering a wide range from 0.5 kW to 2500 kW. Finally, the software package is quite friendly to the user because requires just 5 simple steps before the user can get the desirable output.
Dedicated Analytical SolutionsFOSSSlangerupgade 693400 HillerødTel. +45 70103370
www.foss.dk
The Family owned FOSS group is
the world leader as supplier of
dedicated, high-tech analytical
solutions which measure and
control the quality and produc-
tion of agricultural, food, phar-
maceutical and chemical produ-
cts. Main activities are initiated
from Denmark, Sweden and USA
with headquarters domiciled in
Hillerød, DK. The products are
marketed globally by 23 sales
companies and an extensive net
of distributors. In line with
the corevalue to be ‘First’, the
company intends to expand
its market position.
Employees at FOSS Analytical A/S are living proof of the company value - First - using new inventions to make dedicated solutions for our customers. With sharp minds and cross functional teamwork, we constantly strive to develop new unique products - Would you like to join our team?
FOSS works diligently with innovation and development as basis for its growth. It is reflected in the fact that more than 200 of the 1200 employees in FOSS work with Re-search & Development in Scandinavia and USA. Engineers at FOSS work in production, development and marketing, within a wide range of different fields, i.e. Chemistry, Electronics, Mechanics, Software, Optics, Microbiology, Chemometrics.
Sharp Minds - Bright Ideas!
We offerA challenging job in an international and innovative company that is leading in its field. You will get the opportunity to work with the most advanced technology together with highly skilled colleagues.
Read more about FOSS at www.foss.dk - or go directly to our student site www.foss.dk/sharpminds where you can learn more about your possibilities of working together with us on projects, your thesis etc.
Ple
ase
clic
k th
e ad
vert
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
80
Case Study
At the sheet named ‘Calculations’, [Figure 8.3] the user should enter the following inputs:
1. the annual average wind speed u at standard height z = 10 m 2. the index a which is a parameter relative to surface roughness
The user can find a Table indicating the values to be expected to certain types of terrain at the sheet named ‘Help Menu’.
3. the hub height h. In this software package there are available eight different values of height h i.e. h = 10 m, 20 m, 30 m, 40 m, 50 m, 60 m, 70 m, 80 m. Height requirements for medium and large wind turbines are 20 - 80 m. Height requirements for small wind turbines are up to 20 m.
4. the name of the manufacturer 5. the name of the model
In this software package there is available a database of seven different manufacturers and twenty eight different models of various sizes (from 0,5 kW - 2500 kW)
Figure 8.3: Main menu The user then get the following output:
1. the annual average wind speed v at hub height for the above 8 different values of height h 2. the total Annual Energy Output (AEO) in [GWh/yr]
The ‘Rayleigh Distribution’, [Figure 8.4] shows a graph of a mathematical distribution called the Rayleigh distribution which resembles the distribution of different wind speeds throughout the year. The ‘Wind Speed Frequency’, [Figure 8.5] is showing the number of hours for which the wind blows at different wind speeds, during a given period of time. The ‘Power Curve’, [Figure 8.6] displays the values of instantaneous power in [kW] given from manufacturers for each model of the database of this software package. The ‘Annual Energy Output’, [Figure 8.7] graph displays values of energy in [kWh/yr] for all the wind speeds in the range of 0 - 25 m/sec.
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
81
Case Study
The ‘Wind Speed Vertical Profile’, is shown in [Figure 8.8].
Figure 8.4: The ‘Rayleigh Distribution’
Figure 8.5: The ‘Wind speed frequency’ menu
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
82
Case Study
Figure 8.6: The ‘Power curve’ menu
Ple
ase
clic
k th
e ad
vert
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
83
Case Study
Figure 8.7: The (A.E.O.) menu
Figure 8.8: The ‘Wind speed vertical profile’
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
84
Case Study
8.6 Discussion Consider six different wind turbines with rated power of 600 - 660 kW which is the most common value for most modern wind turbines in the market, shown in Table 1, taken from references [7, 8, 9, 10, and 11].
a/a Manufacturer Model
1. JACOBS 43/600 kW
2. BONUS 44/600 kW
3. NORDEX 43/600 kW
4. TURBOWINDS 48/600 kW
5. VESTAS 42/600 kW
6. VESTAS 47/660 kW
Table 1: Various wind turbines with rated power of 600 - 660 kW
Note that the 2 first digits in the column ‘Model’ of Table 1 represent the diameter D in [m] and the following 3 digits represent the rated output in [kW]. Consider the following values for a given site: u = 4,6 m/sec; a = 0,15; hub height of h = 40 m. The following figures, shows the initial conditions, and Table 2 show the results for the 6 different models.
Figure 8.9 Figure 8.10
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
85
Case Study
a/a Manufacturer Model (A.E.O.) [GWh/yr]
1. JACOBS 43/600 kW 0,966
2. BONUS 44/600 kW 1,009
3. NORDEX 43/600 kW 0,987
4. TURBOWINDS 48/600 kW 1,148
5. VESTAS 42/600 kW 0,903
6. VESTAS 47/660 kW 1,184
Table 2: Annual Wind Energy Output.
From Table 2 the conclusion is that the most beneficial choices are between the VESTAS 47/660 and the TURBOWINDS 48/600. However, further considerations (i.e. the price of the machine, its reliability, and the cost of operation and maintenance) must be examined before the final decision is made.
the globally networked management school www.msm.nl
Don’t miss the train. Take the Shanghai Express @ MSM
If you already have your Bachelor’s degree, and want to gain an international
outlook, you should discover MSM’s Master of Science in Management
in International Business. You can complete it in one year, with a one month
attachment in Shanghai, China.
Why don't you give your career a boost and chek out our website www.msm.nl
For more info please contact [emailprotected]
Boost your Career in Less Than 1 Year
Ple
ase
clic
k th
e ad
vert
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
86
Case Study
Manufacturer / Model (A.E.O.)
Software Package [GWh/yr]
(A.E.O.) Official Data
[GWh/yr]
JACOBS 7.5/10 (2) [5] 0,016 0,013
JACOBS 8.0/15 (2) 0,018 0,015
JACOBS 8.5/17.5 (2) 0,026 0,019
JACOBS 9.5/20 (2) 0,027 0,026
JACOBS 43/600 (3) 0,966 0,878
JACOBS 48/750 (3) 1,212 1,190
JACOBS 77/1500 (4) 3,594 3,516
NORDEX 29/250 (3) [6] 0,452 0,432
NORDEX 43/600 (3) 0,987 0,927
NORDEX 50/800 (3) 1,284 1,264
NORDEX 54/1000 (4) 1,819 1,643
NORDEX 60/1300 (4) 2,326 2,186
NORDEX 80/2500 (4) 4,351 N/A
VESTAS 42/600 (3) [7] 0,903 1,029
VESTAS 47/660 (3) 1,184 N/A
VESTAS 66/1650 (4) 2,807 N/A
VESTAS 66/1750 (4) 3,542 N/A
VESTAS 80/2000 (4) 4,360 N/A
WHISPER 1.5/0.5 (1) [8] 0,0005 0,00043
WHISPER 2.1/0.9 (1) 0,0011 0,0008
WHISPER 2.7/1.0 (1) 0,0015 0,0013
WHISPER 4.5/3.0 (1) 0,005 0,004
BONUS 44/600 (3) [9] 1,009 N/A
BONUS 54/1000 (4) 1,902 N/A
BONUS 62/1300 (4) 2,482 N/A
TURBOWINDS 34/400 (3) [10] 0,619 0,578
TURBOWINDS 48/600 (3) 1,148 1,118
NPS 5.0/3 (1) [11] 0,004 0,005
Table 3: Comparison of (A.E.O.) values between the Software Package data and the Official Technical
data from the manufacturers
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
87
Case Study
(1) for wind turbines of rated power 0,5 - 3,0 kW, hub height h = 10 m (2) for wind turbines of rated power 10 - 20 kW , hub height h = 20 m
(3) for wind turbines of rated power 250 - 999 kW, hub height h = 40 m (4) for wind turbines of rated power 1000 - 2500 kW, hub height h = 70 m
Initial conditions:
Annual average wind speed at a standard height z = 10 m, u = 4,6 m/sec. and Index a = 0,1. However, with this Software Package the user is able to produce calculations from a limited database of twenty eight (28) different wind turbine models. This limitation occurs due to a programming error of the Microsoft Excel program. Nevertheless, the existing database covers a wide range of models of various sizes (from 0,5 - 2500 kW), helping the user to decide on a model of any size and application.
8.7 Conclusions This study has achieved the development of a Software Package, which gives to the user the ability to evaluate the pattern and amount of energy possible to extract from the wind. The package is quite accurate giving that way the opportunity to the user to make the right choice. It computes the wind energy resource evaluation by calculating the Annual Energy Output (A.E.O.), matching the best Turbine for the available wind resource. However, further considerations (i.e. the price of the machine, its reliability, and the cost of operation and maintenance) must be examined before the final decision is made.
8.8 References
[1]: Twidell, J. and Weir, A. (2006) Renewable Energy Resources, published by Taylor & Francis.2nd.ed. [2]: The European Wind Energy Association (EWEA), http://www.ewea.org. [3]: A comparison of methodologies for monthly wind energy estimation(2009) by E. García-Bustamante , J. F. González-Rouco , P. A. Jiménez , J. Navarro, J. P. Montávez . Journal of Wind Energy, Volume 12 Issue 7, Pages 640 – 659. [4]: http://www.jacobs-energie.com [5]: http://www.nordex.dk [6]: http://www.vestas.dk [7]: http://www.baywinds.com
Download free books at BookBooN.com
Wind Turbines
88
Case Study
[8]: http://www.bonus.dk [9]: http://www.turbowinds.com [10]: http://www.worldpowertech.com
www.job.oticon.dk
Ple
ase
clic
k th
e ad
vert